Research · 3 min read
Music and concentration: sometimes it's better to turn it off
In a stressful, demanding task, music raised perceived effort and worsened performance, whatever the tempo.
The experiment
105 people had to plan a vacation trip on a website deliberately designed to frustrate: delays, errors, processes that had to be repeated. Meanwhile they listened to fast music, slow music or silence.
When the task was stressful and demanding, music (at any tempo) made people perceive more effort, and that ended up hurting their actual performance: more errors, more scrolling and more mouse travel. The authors conclude that, in those moments, turning the music off can help.
What the study doesn't say
It doesn't say music always gets in the way. It measured one specific situation: a hard, frustrating task with a lot of mental load. For routine tasks, or for relaxing, the result may be different.
What it means for you
Listen to your own experience. If you're solving something complicated and feel more overwhelmed with music, pausing it is a good decision, not a failure. Background music for concentration should feel light, not ask for your attention.
Sources
- Arboleda et al. A stressful task is when to turn off the music: effect of music on task performance mediated by cognitive effort. 2022.
For information only: it doesn't replace advice from a health professional.